5 Letter to Editor: Honouring Nolan
If I were Lady Mary Nolan, member of the distinguished Boyd family and widow of the famous Australian artist Sir Sidney Nolan who, in 1974, gifted twenty-four of his paintings to the Commonwealth Government to be hung in Lanyon Homestead in the ACT; and if, after his death, the ACT Government charged with the management of that gift removed the paintings and hung them in another place of its own choosing, then I would feel, as Lady Mary herself put it, ‘outraged’ (Megan Doherty, ‘The Battle for Nolan’s Legacy’, The Canberra Times, 26 April 2009)
If I, like her, were eighty-two years old, in failing health and living away from Australia, I would in addition feel helpless, betrayed and abused. And yet, this is what has happened. The removal of Sidney Nolan’s paintings from the Nolan Gallery in the grounds of Lanyon, following damage to the building from a severe hailstorm in January 2006, the refusal of the ACT government to restore the building and reinstall the paintings, despite Lady Mary’s protests, and the ensuing argy-bargy between the Commonwealth and ACT authorities, are nothing short of a disgrace
Is this the way to treat Lady Mary? Is this the way to handle a priceless gift to the nation from a great and generous Australian? Quite apart from the legal niceties, is this how the Commonwealth and the ACT wish to be seen to treat their cultural benefactors? What message does this give to other would-be benefactors? Wouldn’t it completely destroy their faith in the possibility of their wishes about the management of a gift being honoured? Wouldn’t it change their minds about the advisability of giving at all?
Cultural and heritage luminaries like Betty Churcher and Eric Martin have urged the return of the paintings to a restored Nolan Gallery, to honour the wishes of Sir Sidney and his wife. If the ACT government, as current custodian of the works, is not willing to divert to the Nolan Gallery’s restoration some of the monies recently pledged to it by the Commonwealth, then the Commonwealth itself should reassert its ownership rights and return the twenty-four paintings to the nation by reuniting them with the rest of the Nolan collection in the National Gallery of Australia. Only then would the Commonwealth be honouring the spirit of its undertaking to the Nolans; only then could the nation and Lady Mary rest easy in the belief that justice had been done
Ann Kent, July 2009
[Apart from the controversy surrounding this particular bequest, Nolan’s paintings continue to command attention in the nation’s capital through the Australian War Memorial’s current Sidney Nolan: the Gallipoli series exhibition, until 18 November (forthcoming review in AMA); and with work begun on a permanent, more prominent re-installation at the National Gallery of Australia of Nolan’s Ned Kelly series due to be unveiled in 2010. Ed]